Utilization of SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19)-Positive Donor Kidneys

Background: The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network requires documentation of SARS-CoV-2 (COVID) testing status for each potential donor and lower respiratory specimen testing with nucleic acid tests for all donor lungs. In the absence of guidelines for the use of COVID-positive donor kidneys, we sought to examine the clinical characteristics of COVID-positive donors and trends in the utilization of COVID-positive donor kidneys. Method(s): This study used Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients data and included all deceased donors (n=24,940) and recipients (n= 29,478) from June 1, 2020, through April 2, 2022. Variation in donor and recipient characteristics were considered significant at P<.05. Result(s): 1,310 (5.35%) of donors during the observation period had a positive test for COVID-19 with 1,731 (67.70%) kidneys transplanted, 108 (4.22%) not recovered, and 714 (27.92%) recovered but not transplanted. COVID-positive donors differed from COVID-negative or untested donors in terms of race, ethnicity, cause of death, and donation after circulatory death status (all P < .05). 813 recipients (2.76%) received COVID-positive deceased donor kidneys. Recipients of COVID-positive donor kidneys were more likely to be White, not have received a previous transplant, and had greater cold ischemic times (all P < .05). The number of transplants with COVID-positive donors peaked in early 2022 (Figure 1). Adjusted hazard ratios for all-cause graft failure with COVID-positive donors and death were 0.89 (95% CI, 0.62-1.28) and 0.87 (95% CI, 0.52-1.46), respectively. Conclusion(s): Transplant with COVID-positive donor kidneys increased during the study period and is not associated with increased risks for recipients. However, high discard rates for COVID-positive donors and greater cold ischemic times may suggest that such donor kidneys remain difficult to place. Patient- and transplant program-level interventions targeting decision support and risk aversion may be necessary to reduce discard rates for COVID-positive donor kidneys. (Figure Presented).

Racial Barriers to Kidney Transplant After Listing, 2015 - 2020

Purpose: We sought to evaluate racial disparities in access to deceased donor kidney transplant (DDKT) following changes to kidney allocation system (KAS) implemented in 2014. We also aimed to identify candidate factors that were responsible for reducing African American (AA) access to transplant. Method(s): This study used Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipient Data, and included all adult candidates for DDKT on the waitlist between Jan. 1, 2015 and Mar. 12, 2020 (n=233,033). Candidates were classified as African American (AA) or non-African American (non-AA) and categorical differences in waitlist activity and clinical factors were evaluated by chi-square tests. Univariable (e.g. AA race only) and multivariable (e.g. race and combinations of clinical factors) Cox models with the outcome of time to transplant were constructed to evaluate the impact of AA race on access to transplant. Sub-analysis were performed to account for potential confounding from inactive time and the COVID-19 era. Result(s): Of the 233,033 waitlisted candidates during the study period, 76,576 (32.9%) were AA. There were differences in the clinical profiles of AA and non-AA candidates. For instance, AA were more likely to have the following characteristics: higher BMI, blood type B, female, and have higher cPRA (all with p < 0.0001). AA had longer wait times and slower access to the waitlist after initiating dialysis (p < 0.0001). Our most complete multivariable model showed that AA were 16.3% less likely to receive DDKT, [HR: 0.837, (95% CI: 0.821, 0.852)] (Figure 1). Adjusting for dialysis time prior to listing [HR: 0.863 (95% CI: 0.849, 0.877)] and the combination of dialysis time prior to listing and ethnicity [HR: 0.807 (95% CI: 0.793, 0.822)] resulted in the biggest change in HR from the unadjusted model. Conclusion(s): AA have reduced access to DDKT when compared to non-AA in adjusted analyses. Dialysis time prior to listing and ethnicity are the biggest contributors to the disparity in access. The KAS provides increased access for patients with longer time on the waiting list, therefore, the unadjusted model has closer parity between AA and non-AA. However, even the unadjusted model still shows some disparity meaning that changes may still be necessary in the system by with DDK are allocated to candidates. (Figure Presented).

OPTN/SRTR 2020 Annual Data Report: Kidney.

The year 2020 presented significant challenges to the field of kidney transplantation. After increasing each year since 2015 and reaching the highest annual count to date in 2019, the total number of kidney trans- plants decreased slightly, to 23642, in 2020. The decrease in total kidney transplants was due to a decrease in living donor transplants; the number of deceased donor transplants rose in 2020. The number of patients waiting for a kidney transplant in the United States declined slightly in 2020, driven by a slight drop in the number of new candidates added in 2020 and an increase in patients removed from the waiting list owing to death-important patterns that correlated with the COVID-19 pandemic. The complexities of the pandemic were accompanied by other ongoing challenges. Nationwide, only about a quarter of waitlisted patients receive a deceased donor kidney transplant within 5 years, a proportion that varies dramatically by donation service area, from 14.8% to 73.0%. The nonutilization (discard) rate of recovered organs rose to its highest value, at 21.3%, despite a dramatic decline in the discard of organs from hepatitis C-positive donors. Nonutilization rates remain particularly high for Kidney Donor Profile Index ≥85% kidneys and kidneys from which a biopsy specimen was obtained. Due to pandemic-related disruption of living donation in spring 2020, the number of living donor transplants in 2020 declined below annual counts over the last decade. In this context, only a small proportion of the waiting list receives living donor transplants each year, and racial disparities in living donor transplant access persist. As both graft and patient survival continue to improve incrementally, the total number of living kidney transplant recipients with a functioning graft exceeded 250,000 in 2020. Pediatric transplant numbers seem to have been impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic. The total number of pediatric kidney transplants performed decreased to 715 in 2020, from a peak of 872 in 2009. Despite numerous efforts, living donor kidney transplant remains low among pediatric recipients, with continued racial disparities among recipients. Of concern, the rate of deceased donor transplant among pediatric waitlisted candidates continued to decrease, reaching its lowest point in 2020. While this may be partly explained by the COVID-19 pandemic, close attention to this trend is critically important. Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract remain the leading cause of kidney disease in the pediatric population. While most pediatric de- ceased donor recipients receive a kidney from a donor with KDPI less than 35%, most pediatric deceased donor recipients had four or more HLA mis- matches. Graft survival continues to improve, with superior survival for living donor recipients versus deceased donor recipients.

OPTN/SRTR 2020 Annual Data Report: Liver.

This year was marked by the COVID-19 pandemic, which altered transplant program activity and affected waitlist and transplant outcomes. Still, 8906 liver transplants were performed, an all-time high, across 142 centers in the United States, and pretransplant as well as graft and patient survival metrics, continued to improve. Living donation activity decreased after several years of growth. As of June 30, 2020, 98989 liver transplant recipients were alive with a functioning graft, and in the context of increasing liver transplant volume, the size of both the adult and pediatric liver transplant waitlists have decreased. On February 4, 2020, shortly before the pandemic began, a new liver distribution policy based on acuity circles was implemented, replacing donor service area- and region-based boundaries. A policy change to direct pediatric livers to pediatric recipients led to an increase in deceased donor transplant rates and a decrease in pretransplant mortality rate among children, although the absolute number of pediatric transplants did not increase in 2020. Among adults, alcohol-associated liver disease became the predominant indication for liver transplant in 2020. After implementation of the National Liver Review Board and lower waitlist priority for most exception cases in 2019, fewer liver transplants were being performed via exception points, and the transplant rate between those with and without hepatocellular carcinoma has equalized. Women continue to experience higher pretransplant mortality and lower rates of liver transplant than men.

OPTN/SRTR 2020 Annual Data Report: Heart.

As we enter the third year of the new adult heart allocation policy, we are faced with the new challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2020, new listings (adult and pediatric) decreased slightly, with 4000 new listings in 2020, compared with 4087 in 2019; however, the number of adult heart transplants performed continued to increase, to 3715 in 2020. The number of pediatric heart transplants declined from 509 in 2019 to 465 in 2020. One-year and six-month posttransplant mortality rates in adult recipients have increased slightly since 2015 but have not significantly changed over the past decade. Overall, posttransplant mortality rates for adult recipients were 7.4% at six months and 9.4% at one year for transplants in 2019, 14.0% at three years for transplants in 2017, and 19.1% at five years for transplants in 2015. Although shorter-term posttransplant mortality rates have slightly increased, there has been a steady downward trend in longer-term mortality. Mortality rates for pediatric recipients were 5.7% at six months and 8.1% at one year for transplants in 2019, 11.6% at three years for transplants in 2017, and 15.2% at five years for transplants in 2015.

OPTN/SRTR 2020 Annual Data Report: DOD.

SRTR uses data collected by OPTN to calculate metrics such as donation rate, organ yield, and rate of organs recovered for transplant but not transplanted. In 2020, there were 12,588 deceased donors, an increase from 11,870 in 2019; this number has been increasing since 2010. The number of deceased donor transplants increased to 33,303 in 2020, from 32,313 in 2019; this number has been increasing since 2012. The increase may be due in part to the rising number of deaths of young people amid the ongoing opioid epidemic. The number of organs transplanted included 18,410 kidneys, 962 pancreata, 8350 livers, 91 intestines, 3722 hearts, and 2463 lungs. Compared with 2019, transplants of all organs except pancreata and lung transplants increased in 2020, which is remarkable despite the pandemic caused by the SARS-CoV2 virus. In 2020, 4870 kidneys, 294 pancreata, 861 livers, 3 intestines, 39 hearts, and 115 lungs were discarded. The number of discards was similar to that of the previous year. In 2019, 4,324 kidneys, 346 pancreata, 867 livers, 5 intestines, 31 hearts, and 148 lungs were discarded. These numbers suggest an opportunity to increase numbers of transplants by reducing discards. Despite the pandemic, there was no dramatic increase in number of discards and an increase in total number of donors and transplants.